Two Federal Circuit Decisions Nullify Nine-Figure Damages Awards
In two June 2025 decisions, the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals rejected patent infringement jury verdicts for $218.5 million and $300 million—one reversed for claiming patent ineligible subject matter, and the other vacated due to an improper question on the jury verdict form for infringement.
First, in United Services Automobile Association v. PNC Bank N.A., USAA’s patent assertion campaign relating to remote check deposit technology against various banks over the past several years hit a roadblock when the Federal Circuit determined the asserted USAA patents were patent ineligible under 35 U.S.C. § 101 for claiming an abstract idea, which negated the $218.5 million damages award against PNC Bank.
The trial court in the Eastern District of Texas granted summary judgment for USAA that its patents were patent eligible—finding the claims not directed to an abstract idea under Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank Int’l. On appeal, PNC Bank argued that the district court’s grant of summary judgment was erroneous, and that the patent claims are invalid under § 101 for claiming an abstract idea. The Federal Circuit agreed, and issued two related June 12, 2025, opinions reversing the district court’s summary judgment of patent eligibility. The Federal Circuit went one step further and determined the claims from the USAA patents were ineligible for claiming an abstract idea without an inventive concept under Alice.
Using the two-step analysis from Alice, the Federal Circuit first determined in Step 1 that “the claims are directed to the abstract idea of depositing a check using a handheld mobile device,” because the claim elements recite well-known steps taken when depositing checks using general-purpose hardware, do not claim how to carry out the required claims steps but merely contain results-oriented claim language that does not contain a non-abstract technical solution.
The Court’s Step 2 analysis concluded that the claims contained no inventive concept that transforms the abstract claims into a patent eligible application. The Court rejected USAA’s argument that its patents solved a technological problem of accurate detection and extraction of information from digital images of checks. It found that the claims merely use routine or conventional activities long associated with depositing checks using general-purpose mobile devices. With the patent’s ineligible for patent protection, the infringement and damages verdict cannot stand.
Second, in Optus Cellular Technology, LLC v. Apple Inc., the Federal Circuit vacated an infringement and damages judgment, and remanded for a new trial, because the district court’s jury verdict form question on infringement violated Apple’s right to a unanimous jury decision. Despite the parties’ request for separate questions for each of the five asserted patents, the district court included only a single question asking whether “Apple infringed ANY of the asserted claims?” The affirmative response to that question led to a $300 million damages award.
On appeal, Apple argued that the single question for five patents erroneously required an affirmative answer, even if none of the five patents were unanimously found to infringe. As the Court noted, if each juror believed at least one claim of one patent was infringed, then the jury was required to answer “yes” to the infringement question. That would be true even if the various jurors believed a different patent was infringed, which would not constitute a unanimous determination of infringement of any one patent.
This article is available in the Jenner & Block Japan Newsletter. / この記事はJenner & Blockニュースレターに掲載されています。
Using the two-step analysis from Alice, the Federal Circuit first determined in Step 1 that “the claims are directed to the abstract idea of depositing a check using a handheld mobile device,” because the claim elements recite well-known steps taken when depositing checks using general-purpose hardware, do not claim how to carry out the required claims steps but merely contain results-oriented claim language that does not contain a non-abstract technical solution.
The Court’s Step 2 analysis concluded that the claims contained no inventive concept that transforms the abstract claims into a patent eligible application. The Court rejected USAA’s argument that its patents solved a technological problem of accurate detection and extraction of information from digital images of checks. It found that the claims merely use routine or conventional activities long associated with depositing checks using general-purpose mobile devices. With the patent’s ineligible for patent protection, the infringement and damages verdict cannot stand.
Second, in Optus Cellular Technology, LLC v. Apple Inc., the Federal Circuit vacated an infringement and damages judgment, and remanded for a new trial, because the district court’s jury verdict form question on infringement violated Apple’s right to a unanimous jury decision. Despite the parties’ request for separate questions for each of the five asserted patents, the district court included only a single question asking whether “Apple infringed ANY of the asserted claims?” The affirmative response to that question led to a $300 million damages award.
On appeal, Apple argued that the single question for five patents erroneously required an affirmative answer, even if none of the five patents were unanimously found to infringe. As the Court noted, if each juror believed at least one claim of one patent was infringed, then the jury was required to answer “yes” to the infringement question. That would be true even if the various jurors believed a different patent was infringed, which would not constitute a unanimous determination of infringement of any one patent.
This article is available in the Jenner & Block Japan Newsletter. / この記事はJenner & Blockニュースレターに掲載されています。
Related Lawyers
Related Articles
Related Capabilities
© 2026 Jenner & Block LLP. Attorney Advertising. Jenner & Block LLP is an Illinois Limited Liability Partnership including professional corporations. This publication, presentation, or event is not intended to provide legal advice but to provide information on legal matters and/or firm news of interest to our clients and colleagues. Readers or attendees should seek specific legal advice before taking any action with respect to matters mentioned in this publication or at this event. The attorney responsible for this communication is Brent E. Kidwell, Jenner & Block LLP, 353 N. Clark Street, Chicago, IL 60654-3456. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Jenner & Block London LLP, an affiliate of Jenner & Block LLP, is a limited liability partnership established under the laws of the State of Delaware, USA and is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority with SRA number 615729. Information regarding the data we collect and the rights you have over your data can be found in our Privacy Notice. For further inquiries, please contact dataprotection@jenner.com.
In two June 2025 decisions, the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals rejected patent infringement jury verdicts for $218.5 million and $300 million—one reversed for claiming patent ineligible subject matter, and the other vacated due to an improper question on the jury verdict form for infringement.
First, in United Services Automobile Association v. PNC Bank N.A., USAA’s patent assertion campaign relating to remote check deposit technology against various banks over the past several years hit a roadblock when the Federal Circuit determined the asserted USAA patents were patent ineligible under 35 U.S.C. § 101 for claiming an abstract idea, which negated the $218.5 million damages award against PNC Bank.
The trial court in the Eastern District of Texas granted summary judgment for USAA that its patents were patent eligible—finding the claims not directed to an abstract idea under Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank Int’l. On appeal, PNC Bank argued that the district court’s grant of summary judgment was erroneous, and that the patent claims are invalid under § 101 for claiming an abstract idea. The Federal Circuit agreed, and issued two related June 12, 2025, opinions reversing the district court’s summary judgment of patent eligibility. The Federal Circuit went one step further and determined the claims from the USAA patents were ineligible for claiming an abstract idea without an inventive concept under Alice.
Using the two-step analysis from Alice, the Federal Circuit first determined in Step 1 that “the claims are directed to the abstract idea of depositing a check using a handheld mobile device,” because the claim elements recite well-known steps taken when depositing checks using general-purpose hardware, do not claim how to carry out the required claims steps but merely contain results-oriented claim language that does not contain a non-abstract technical solution.
The Court’s Step 2 analysis concluded that the claims contained no inventive concept that transforms the abstract claims into a patent eligible application. The Court rejected USAA’s argument that its patents solved a technological problem of accurate detection and extraction of information from digital images of checks. It found that the claims merely use routine or conventional activities long associated with depositing checks using general-purpose mobile devices. With the patent’s ineligible for patent protection, the infringement and damages verdict cannot stand.
Second, in Optus Cellular Technology, LLC v. Apple Inc., the Federal Circuit vacated an infringement and damages judgment, and remanded for a new trial, because the district court’s jury verdict form question on infringement violated Apple’s right to a unanimous jury decision. Despite the parties’ request for separate questions for each of the five asserted patents, the district court included only a single question asking whether “Apple infringed ANY of the asserted claims?” The affirmative response to that question led to a $300 million damages award.
On appeal, Apple argued that the single question for five patents erroneously required an affirmative answer, even if none of the five patents were unanimously found to infringe. As the Court noted, if each juror believed at least one claim of one patent was infringed, then the jury was required to answer “yes” to the infringement question. That would be true even if the various jurors believed a different patent was infringed, which would not constitute a unanimous determination of infringement of any one patent.
This article is available in the Jenner & Block Japan Newsletter. / この記事はJenner & Blockニュースレターに掲載されています。
Using the two-step analysis from Alice, the Federal Circuit first determined in Step 1 that “the claims are directed to the abstract idea of depositing a check using a handheld mobile device,” because the claim elements recite well-known steps taken when depositing checks using general-purpose hardware, do not claim how to carry out the required claims steps but merely contain results-oriented claim language that does not contain a non-abstract technical solution.
The Court’s Step 2 analysis concluded that the claims contained no inventive concept that transforms the abstract claims into a patent eligible application. The Court rejected USAA’s argument that its patents solved a technological problem of accurate detection and extraction of information from digital images of checks. It found that the claims merely use routine or conventional activities long associated with depositing checks using general-purpose mobile devices. With the patent’s ineligible for patent protection, the infringement and damages verdict cannot stand.
Second, in Optus Cellular Technology, LLC v. Apple Inc., the Federal Circuit vacated an infringement and damages judgment, and remanded for a new trial, because the district court’s jury verdict form question on infringement violated Apple’s right to a unanimous jury decision. Despite the parties’ request for separate questions for each of the five asserted patents, the district court included only a single question asking whether “Apple infringed ANY of the asserted claims?” The affirmative response to that question led to a $300 million damages award.
On appeal, Apple argued that the single question for five patents erroneously required an affirmative answer, even if none of the five patents were unanimously found to infringe. As the Court noted, if each juror believed at least one claim of one patent was infringed, then the jury was required to answer “yes” to the infringement question. That would be true even if the various jurors believed a different patent was infringed, which would not constitute a unanimous determination of infringement of any one patent.
This article is available in the Jenner & Block Japan Newsletter. / この記事はJenner & Blockニュースレターに掲載されています。
Related Lawyers
Related Articles
Related Capabilities
© 2026 Jenner & Block LLP. Attorney Advertising. Jenner & Block LLP is an Illinois Limited Liability Partnership including professional corporations. This publication, presentation, or event is not intended to provide legal advice but to provide information on legal matters and/or firm news of interest to our clients and colleagues. Readers or attendees should seek specific legal advice before taking any action with respect to matters mentioned in this publication or at this event. The attorney responsible for this communication is Brent E. Kidwell, Jenner & Block LLP, 353 N. Clark Street, Chicago, IL 60654-3456. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Jenner & Block London LLP, an affiliate of Jenner & Block LLP, is a limited liability partnership established under the laws of the State of Delaware, USA and is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority with SRA number 615729. Information regarding the data we collect and the rights you have over your data can be found in our Privacy Notice. For further inquiries, please contact dataprotection@jenner.com.
News and Insights
Publications
From Four Remedies to Multiple Pressures: The New Risk Model for Government Contractors and Grantees, Government Contractor
Partners David Robbins, Emily Loeb, and Matthew Haws and Associate Rachel Palermo authored an article for Government Contractor examining how the oversight landscape is changing for government contractors, grant recipients, universities, and nonprofits, and what general counsel and boards should do in response.
November 18, 2026
Recognition
Partner Lindsay Harrison Named a 2026 Law360 Real Estate MVP
Law360 named Lindsay Harrison, Co-Chair of the firm’s Real Estate and Hospitality Practice, a 2026 MVP in the Real Estate category.
November 18, 2026
Publications
In The American Lawyer, “My Client Is Often the Truth”: Neil Barofsky on What Matters Most
Partner Neil Barofsky, who was a finalist for Attorney of the Year at the publication’s 2026 Industry Awards, was profiled in The American Lawyer. The article examines what independence requires of a monitor or ombudsperson who oversees reforms after things have gone wrong and how that commitment has shaped his work.
November 16, 2026
Publications
New York Court Allows Attorney General’s Zelle Fraud Lawsuit to Proceed, In New York Law Journal
Partners Jeremy Creelan, Megan Poetzel, Laurel Loomis Rimon, and Michael Ross and Associate Julian Buff authored an article for the New York Law Journal examining a recent New York trial court decision allowing the New York Office of the Attorney General’s (OAG) lawsuit against Early Warning Services, LLC, the owner of the payment service Zelle, to proceed to discovery.
November 16, 2026
News
In Billboard, Partner Precious Jacobs Discusses the Rise in Artist-Manager Litigation
Partner Precious S. Jacobs was featured in Billboard in “It’s Not Just Timbaland: Why Are So Many Artists Suing Their Managers Right Now?.” The article examines the recent wave of lawsuits between music artists and their managers and why that relationship is so prone to conflict.
November 12, 2026