Delaware Supreme Court Reaffirms Reluctance to Blue-Pencil Overbroad Restrictive Covenants in Sunder v. Jackson

The Delaware Supreme Court’s decision in Sunder Energy, LLV v. Jackson, No. 455, 2023, 2024 Del. LEXIS 407 (December 10, 2024) reaffirmed the courts’ limited willingness to modify or “blue-pencil” overbroad restrictive covenants, emphasizing the importance of freedom of contract and the need for carefully drafted agreements. This case arose when Sunder Energy, a solar sales dealer, sought to enforce restrictive covenants against Tyler Jackson, a minority member and former employee who joined a competitor, Solar Pros.

The restrictive covenants prohibited Jackson and his “affiliates” from engaging in door-to-door sales in Sunder’s markets or soliciting Sunder’s employees. The Delaware Court of Chancery found these provisions overbroad and unreasonable. One provision was deemed so expansive that it could theoretically prevent Jackson’s daughter from selling Girl Scout cookies door‑to‑door. Additionally, the noncompete’s duration was indefinite because it depended on Sunder’s discretion to repurchase Jackson’s incentive units. The court concluded that these restrictions exceeded any legitimate business interest Sunder might have.

Sunder argued that the court should blue-pencil the covenants to make them enforceable, as Jackson’s actions would have breached even a narrower restriction. However, the Court of Chancery declined, reasoning that modifying such agreements would incentivize employers to draft overly broad covenants with the expectation that the courts would rewrite them later. The court emphasized that fairness and enforceability must be evaluated based on each covenant’s terms and the circumstances under which they were adopted—not the conduct of the restricted party.

Supreme Court Affirms: No Blue-Penciling Without Fair Bargaining

On appeal, the Delaware Supreme Court upheld this decision, affirming that blue-penciling is a matter of judicial discretion and should be applied sparingly. The Court noted that blue-penciling is typically reserved for cases where there is an equality of bargaining power between parties, such as when restrictive covenants are negotiated in good faith, supported by valuable consideration, or arise from a business sale. In this case, none of those factors were present.

The Court highlighted several key facts undermining Sunder’s position:

  • Jackson did not participate in negotiating or discussing the restrictive covenants’ terms.
  • The operating agreement was sent to Jackson for electronic signature on New Year’s Eve with instructions to sign before midnight, leaving him no meaningful opportunity to review or seek legal advice.
  • Jackson received little to no separate compensation for agreeing to the covenants; instead, he was granted incentive units that he could not freely transfer, and which were later repurchased by Sunder for $0 when he left under “bad leaver” status.

The Delaware Supreme Court rejected Sunder’s request to rewrite the covenants entirely, stating that such relief would contradict Delaware’s strong commitment to freedom of contract. Courts cannot craft entirely new agreements for parties who failed to negotiate reasonable terms themselves.

Implications for Employers: Draft Narrowly Tailored Covenants

The Sunder decision reflects a growing trend in Delaware courts to strike down overbroad restrictive covenants rather than modify them. This approach underscores the importance of narrowly tailoring noncompete and nonsolicitation provisions to protect only legitimate business interests. Employers should ensure these agreements are fair, supported by adequate consideration, and provide sufficient time for review and legal consultation.

The ruling serves as a reminder that courts will not rescue sophisticated parties from their own overly aggressive contractual terms. Instead, businesses must carefully draft enforceable agreements from the outset to avoid reliance on judicial intervention.

This article is available in the Jenner & Block Japan Newsletter. / この記事はJenner & Blockニュースレターに掲載されています。

Related Capabilities

© 2026 Jenner & Block LLP. Attorney Advertising. Jenner & Block LLP is an Illinois Limited Liability Partnership including professional corporations. This publication, presentation, or event is not intended to provide legal advice but to provide information on legal matters and/or firm news of interest to our clients and colleagues. Readers or attendees should seek specific legal advice before taking any action with respect to matters mentioned in this publication or at this event. The attorney responsible for this communication is Brent E. Kidwell, Jenner & Block LLP, 353 N. Clark Street, Chicago, IL 60654-3456. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Jenner & Block London LLP, an affiliate of Jenner & Block LLP, is a limited liability partnership established under the laws of the State of Delaware, USA and is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority with SRA number 615729. Information regarding the data we collect and the rights you have over your data can be found in our Privacy Notice. For further inquiries, please contact dataprotection@jenner.com.

Delaware Supreme Court Reaffirms Reluctance to Blue-Pencil Overbroad Restrictive Covenants in Sunder v. Jackson

The Delaware Supreme Court’s decision in Sunder Energy, LLV v. Jackson, No. 455, 2023, 2024 Del. LEXIS 407 (December 10, 2024) reaffirmed the courts’ limited willingness to modify or “blue-pencil” overbroad restrictive covenants, emphasizing the importance of freedom of contract and the need for carefully drafted agreements. This case arose when Sunder Energy, a solar sales dealer, sought to enforce restrictive covenants against Tyler Jackson, a minority member and former employee who joined a competitor, Solar Pros.

The restrictive covenants prohibited Jackson and his “affiliates” from engaging in door-to-door sales in Sunder’s markets or soliciting Sunder’s employees. The Delaware Court of Chancery found these provisions overbroad and unreasonable. One provision was deemed so expansive that it could theoretically prevent Jackson’s daughter from selling Girl Scout cookies door‑to‑door. Additionally, the noncompete’s duration was indefinite because it depended on Sunder’s discretion to repurchase Jackson’s incentive units. The court concluded that these restrictions exceeded any legitimate business interest Sunder might have.

Sunder argued that the court should blue-pencil the covenants to make them enforceable, as Jackson’s actions would have breached even a narrower restriction. However, the Court of Chancery declined, reasoning that modifying such agreements would incentivize employers to draft overly broad covenants with the expectation that the courts would rewrite them later. The court emphasized that fairness and enforceability must be evaluated based on each covenant’s terms and the circumstances under which they were adopted—not the conduct of the restricted party.

Supreme Court Affirms: No Blue-Penciling Without Fair Bargaining

On appeal, the Delaware Supreme Court upheld this decision, affirming that blue-penciling is a matter of judicial discretion and should be applied sparingly. The Court noted that blue-penciling is typically reserved for cases where there is an equality of bargaining power between parties, such as when restrictive covenants are negotiated in good faith, supported by valuable consideration, or arise from a business sale. In this case, none of those factors were present.

The Court highlighted several key facts undermining Sunder’s position:

  • Jackson did not participate in negotiating or discussing the restrictive covenants’ terms.
  • The operating agreement was sent to Jackson for electronic signature on New Year’s Eve with instructions to sign before midnight, leaving him no meaningful opportunity to review or seek legal advice.
  • Jackson received little to no separate compensation for agreeing to the covenants; instead, he was granted incentive units that he could not freely transfer, and which were later repurchased by Sunder for $0 when he left under “bad leaver” status.

The Delaware Supreme Court rejected Sunder’s request to rewrite the covenants entirely, stating that such relief would contradict Delaware’s strong commitment to freedom of contract. Courts cannot craft entirely new agreements for parties who failed to negotiate reasonable terms themselves.

Implications for Employers: Draft Narrowly Tailored Covenants

The Sunder decision reflects a growing trend in Delaware courts to strike down overbroad restrictive covenants rather than modify them. This approach underscores the importance of narrowly tailoring noncompete and nonsolicitation provisions to protect only legitimate business interests. Employers should ensure these agreements are fair, supported by adequate consideration, and provide sufficient time for review and legal consultation.

The ruling serves as a reminder that courts will not rescue sophisticated parties from their own overly aggressive contractual terms. Instead, businesses must carefully draft enforceable agreements from the outset to avoid reliance on judicial intervention.

This article is available in the Jenner & Block Japan Newsletter. / この記事はJenner & Blockニュースレターに掲載されています。

Related Capabilities

© 2026 Jenner & Block LLP. Attorney Advertising. Jenner & Block LLP is an Illinois Limited Liability Partnership including professional corporations. This publication, presentation, or event is not intended to provide legal advice but to provide information on legal matters and/or firm news of interest to our clients and colleagues. Readers or attendees should seek specific legal advice before taking any action with respect to matters mentioned in this publication or at this event. The attorney responsible for this communication is Brent E. Kidwell, Jenner & Block LLP, 353 N. Clark Street, Chicago, IL 60654-3456. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Jenner & Block London LLP, an affiliate of Jenner & Block LLP, is a limited liability partnership established under the laws of the State of Delaware, USA and is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority with SRA number 615729. Information regarding the data we collect and the rights you have over your data can be found in our Privacy Notice. For further inquiries, please contact dataprotection@jenner.com.

News and Insights

Publications

From Four Remedies to Multiple Pressures: The New Risk Model for Government Contractors and Grantees, Government Contractor

Partners David Robbins, Emily Loeb, and Matthew Haws and Associate Rachel Palermo authored an article for Government Contractor examining how the oversight landscape is changing for government contractors, grant recipients, universities, and nonprofits, and what general counsel and boards should do in response.

November 18, 2026

Recognition

Partner Lindsay Harrison Named a 2026 Law360 Real Estate MVP

Law360 named Lindsay Harrison, Co-Chair of the firm’s Real Estate and Hospitality Practice, a 2026 MVP in the Real Estate category.

November 18, 2026

Publications

In The American Lawyer, “My Client Is Often the Truth”: Neil Barofsky on What Matters Most

Partner Neil Barofsky, who was a finalist for Attorney of the Year at the publication’s 2026 Industry Awards, was profiled in The American Lawyer. The article examines what independence requires of a monitor or ombudsperson who oversees reforms after things have gone wrong and how that commitment has shaped his work.

 

November 16, 2026

Publications

New York Court Allows Attorney General’s Zelle Fraud Lawsuit to Proceed, In New York Law Journal

Partners Jeremy Creelan, Megan Poetzel, Laurel Loomis Rimon, and Michael Ross and Associate Julian Buff authored an article for the New York Law Journal examining a recent New York trial court decision allowing the New York Office of the Attorney General’s (OAG) lawsuit against Early Warning Services, LLC, the owner of the payment service Zelle, to proceed to discovery.

November 16, 2026

News

In Billboard, Partner Precious Jacobs Discusses the Rise in Artist-Manager Litigation

Partner Precious S. Jacobs was featured in Billboard in “It’s Not Just Timbaland: Why Are So Many Artists Suing Their Managers Right Now?.” The article examines the recent wave of lawsuits between music artists and their managers and why that relationship is so prone to conflict.

November 12, 2026

Event

Partner Terri Mascherin to Speak at Illinois State Bar Association Seminar on Negotiation Ethics

On November 11, Partner Terri Mascherin will join a faculty panel for the Illinois State Bar Association (ISBA) continuing legal education (CLE) seminar “Negotiation Ethics: Winning Without Selling Your Soul.”

November 11, 2026