Client Alert: Fifth Circuit Holds SEC's In-House Forum is Unconstitutional

When Congress passed the Dodd-Frank Act, it expanded the SEC’s power to use its in-house administrative forum to bring enforcement actions. Supporters said this change promoted investor protection by giving the SEC a more efficient avenue in an expanded set of cases. Almost a decade after Dodd-Frank was passed, however, this benefit has not materialized. Instead, the SEC’s in-house forum has been subject to repeated constitutional attacks and has been criticized for failing to serve as a fair forum to litigate cases to final judgment more quickly. 

Most recently, a divided panel of the Fifth Circuit in Jarkesy v. Securities and Exchange Commission, No. 20-61007 (5th Cir. May 18, 2022), found that the use of in-house administrative law judges (ALJs) by the SEC is unconstitutional because it violates the Seventh Amendment’s right to a jury trial, reflects an impermissible delegation of authority to the agency, and features adjudicators that are improperly insulated from removal. Each of these holdings is interesting in its own right and may provide fodder for other litigants seeking to cast doubt on the actions of ALJs used by the SEC and perhaps other federal agencies. This article describes the issues at play in the case and discusses how the continuing uncertainty of the constitutionality of the SEC’s in-house forum may impact the agency going forward.

Read the full alert here.

Related Capabilities

Related Locations

© 2026 Jenner & Block LLP. Attorney Advertising. Jenner & Block LLP is an Illinois Limited Liability Partnership including professional corporations. This publication, presentation, or event is not intended to provide legal advice but to provide information on legal matters and/or firm news of interest to our clients and colleagues. Readers or attendees should seek specific legal advice before taking any action with respect to matters mentioned in this publication or at this event. The attorney responsible for this communication is Brent E. Kidwell, Jenner & Block LLP, 353 N. Clark Street, Chicago, IL 60654-3456. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Jenner & Block London LLP, an affiliate of Jenner & Block LLP, is a limited liability partnership established under the laws of the State of Delaware, USA and is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority with SRA number 615729. Information regarding the data we collect and the rights you have over your data can be found in our Privacy Notice. For further inquiries, please contact dataprotection@jenner.com.

Client Alert: Fifth Circuit Holds SEC's In-House Forum is Unconstitutional

When Congress passed the Dodd-Frank Act, it expanded the SEC’s power to use its in-house administrative forum to bring enforcement actions. Supporters said this change promoted investor protection by giving the SEC a more efficient avenue in an expanded set of cases. Almost a decade after Dodd-Frank was passed, however, this benefit has not materialized. Instead, the SEC’s in-house forum has been subject to repeated constitutional attacks and has been criticized for failing to serve as a fair forum to litigate cases to final judgment more quickly. 

Most recently, a divided panel of the Fifth Circuit in Jarkesy v. Securities and Exchange Commission, No. 20-61007 (5th Cir. May 18, 2022), found that the use of in-house administrative law judges (ALJs) by the SEC is unconstitutional because it violates the Seventh Amendment’s right to a jury trial, reflects an impermissible delegation of authority to the agency, and features adjudicators that are improperly insulated from removal. Each of these holdings is interesting in its own right and may provide fodder for other litigants seeking to cast doubt on the actions of ALJs used by the SEC and perhaps other federal agencies. This article describes the issues at play in the case and discusses how the continuing uncertainty of the constitutionality of the SEC’s in-house forum may impact the agency going forward.

Read the full alert here.

Related Capabilities

Related Locations

© 2026 Jenner & Block LLP. Attorney Advertising. Jenner & Block LLP is an Illinois Limited Liability Partnership including professional corporations. This publication, presentation, or event is not intended to provide legal advice but to provide information on legal matters and/or firm news of interest to our clients and colleagues. Readers or attendees should seek specific legal advice before taking any action with respect to matters mentioned in this publication or at this event. The attorney responsible for this communication is Brent E. Kidwell, Jenner & Block LLP, 353 N. Clark Street, Chicago, IL 60654-3456. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Jenner & Block London LLP, an affiliate of Jenner & Block LLP, is a limited liability partnership established under the laws of the State of Delaware, USA and is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority with SRA number 615729. Information regarding the data we collect and the rights you have over your data can be found in our Privacy Notice. For further inquiries, please contact dataprotection@jenner.com.

News and Insights

Event

Amanda Shafer Berman to Speak on Energy and Administrative Law at WEN-DC Webinar

As the Supreme Court's new Term begins, Jenner & Block Partner Amanda Shafer Berman will join a Women's Energy Network of Washington, DC (WEN-DC) webinar on how the Court's decisions are shaping the energy sector.

October 14, 2026

Publications

Partner Amanda Shafer Berman Quoted in Bloomberg Law on Senate Permitting Overhaul Bill

Partner Amanda Shafer Berman was quoted in an October 5 Bloomberg Law article, "Permitting Deal Gives Projects Defense Against Litigation Delays," on the Senate's new permitting overhaul package and its expected impact on litigation over federal permitting reversals.

October 2026

Event

Partner John Storino to Speak at Sandpiper Partners' “AI and Outside Counsel Guidelines Roundtable”

On October 8, Partner John Storino will serve as a panelist at the “AI and Outside Counsel Guidelines Roundtable,” hosted by Sandpiper Partners in Chicago.

October 8, 2026

Event

Partner Meghan Greenfield to Speak on Supreme Court Climate Case at Edison Electric Institute's Fall Legal Conference

On Wednesday, October 7, Partner Meghan Greenfield will speak on a panel titled "Boulder County v. Suncor Energy: What the Supreme Court's Climate Case Means for the Energy Industry" at the Edison Electric Institute's Fall Legal Conference in Salt Lake City, Utah.

October 7, 2026

Publications

The Form Rules Everything: A Seventh Circuit Ruling on ERISA's Substantial Compliance Doctrine

Partner Joseph Torres and Special Counsel Jennifer Beach authored an article for Employee Relations Law Journal examining the Seventh Circuit's decision in Packaging Corp. of America Thrift Plan for Hourly Employees v. Langdon, a ruling that addresses both the standard of review in ERISA interpleader actions and the continued viability of the substantial compliance doctrine for changing plan beneficiaries.

October 5, 2026